Justia Construction Law Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in Contracts
by
A couple entered into an agreement with a construction company to build a home on their property. The contract was signed at a time when the construction company’s registration as a contractor had lapsed, which violated the Idaho Contractor Registration Act (ICRA). During construction, numerous problems arose, including water leaks, mold, improper grading, and unfinished work. The couple paid substantial sums and alleged that the company issued fraudulent invoices for work not performed. After failed attempts to resolve the issues, the couple sued for breach of contract, breach of implied warranty of merchantability, and fraudulent billing. The construction company counterclaimed, arguing it was prevented from completing the work and that its registration lapse was inadvertent.The District Court of the Second Judicial District, Clearwater County, initially dismissed the construction company’s counterclaims due to its failure to register under ICRA. Later, the court granted summary judgment to the construction company, dismissing the couple’s claims and finding the contract void and unenforceable because of the registration violation. The court reasoned that neither party could enforce the contract and denied all claims arising from it, including those for breach of contract and fraudulent billing.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho reviewed the summary judgment de novo. The Court held that while ICRA prohibits an unregistered contractor from enforcing a contract, it does not bar the innocent project owner from doing so. Contracts entered in violation of ICRA are voidable, not void, and remain enforceable at the option of the project owner. The Supreme Court reversed the district court’s dismissal of the couple’s breach of contract claim and remanded for further proceedings, clarifying that the project owner may pursue claims under such a contract. Attorney fees were denied, but costs were awarded to the prevailing party. View "Kumm v. Work Shops & Sons " on Justia Law

by
Maria Diaz contracted with a franchisee, SOL Pools, LLC, to build a swimming pool, while SOL Pools operated as a franchisee of Premier Franchise Management, LLC. Diaz initially brought a small claims action in 2022 against SOL for breach of contract and property damage, resulting in a default judgment in her favor. Subsequently, in 2023, Diaz filed suit in district court against both SOL and Premier, alleging breach of contract, fraud, negligence, and violations of the Home Repair Fraud Act, including claims against Premier based on apparent authority. SOL again failed to appear, leading to a default judgment against SOL for damages and punitive damages.The District Court of Oklahoma County allowed Premier to amend the pretrial conference order to assert the defense of res judicata, relying on the prior small claims judgment. The district court then vacated the default judgment against SOL, dismissed Diaz’s claims against SOL with prejudice, and dismissed Diaz’s apparent authority claims against Premier based on claim preclusion. The district court certified its order for immediate appeal under Oklahoma law, and Diaz sought review by petition for certiorari.The Supreme Court of the State of Oklahoma granted certiorari. It held that the district court did not abuse its discretion by permitting Premier to amend the pretrial conference order to add the defense of res judicata. However, it found that the district court erred in dismissing Diaz’s apparent authority claims against Premier without first developing the necessary factual record to determine whether claim preclusion applies under Oklahoma law. The Supreme Court reversed the district court’s certified interlocutory order in part and remanded for further proceedings consistent with its opinion. View "DIAZ v. PREMIER FRANCHISE MANAGEMENT, LLC" on Justia Law

by
Derek and Keisha Hall hired Jose Silva to construct their new home and financed the project through Priority One Bank, where Harvey Lott served as the loan officer. The Halls later discovered construction defects and alleged that Silva, Lott, and the bank engaged in a secret arrangement for personal profit, including unauthorized loan disbursements and a failure to conduct proper inspections. The Halls also claimed Silva lacked a contractor’s license and that the relationship between Silva and Lott involved improper payments. Both Lott and the bank denied these allegations, asserting that bank inspections were for their own benefit and that loan advances sometimes occurred before work was completed, in line with their agreement.The Halls brought several claims against the bank, Lott, and Silva in the Jefferson Davis County Circuit Court, including breach of contract, fraud, and conspiracy. In response, the bank and Lott sought summary judgment, but the circuit court denied their motion, finding that genuine issues of material fact remained. Subsequently, the Halls moved to strike a provision in the loan agreement, arguing it was unconscionable and deprived them of legal remedies. The circuit court granted this motion, holding the provision was void, invalid, and unconscionable.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed the case on interlocutory appeal. It held that the Halls’ “Motion to Strike Contract Provision” was not an appropriate procedural vehicle to challenge the enforceability of a contract provision, as motions to strike under Mississippi Rule of Civil Procedure 12(f) are limited to pleadings, not contract clauses. The court reversed the circuit court’s order striking the provision and remanded the case for further proceedings, directing that any challenge to the provision’s enforceability must follow the proper procedures for dispositive motions. View "Priority One Bank v. Hall" on Justia Law

by
A taxpayer challenged a California school district’s use of a “lease-leaseback” arrangement with a contractor for constructing a new middle school. The plaintiff alleged the $36 million construction contract violated California’s competitive bidding statutes and conflict of interest laws. The district had selected the contractor from a prequalified pool and entered into preconstruction agreements, then executed lease-leaseback contracts for the project. The project was funded entirely by the proceeds of bonds approved by local voters, not by contractor-provided financing.Previously, the Superior Court of Fresno County dismissed the complaint, but on the first appeal, the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, held that the plaintiff had stated claims for both competitive bidding and conflict of interest violations. After further proceedings and another appeal, the California Supreme Court confirmed that the validation statutes did not bar the action, and the case proceeded to a bench trial. The trial court found the lease-leaseback arrangement qualified for the statutory exception to competitive bidding and rejected the conflict of interest claim, concluding the contractor was not an “officer” or “employee” for purposes of the conflict of interest statute.On appeal, the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, held that the conflict of interest claim was properly rejected because the contractor did not act as an officer or employee of the district. However, the court concluded that the competitive bidding exception did not apply because the project was financed by public bonds, not by the contractor. The court held that the proper remedy under Education Code section 17406(d)—enacted after the initial appeal—was to require the contractor to disgorge its net profit ($236,129), not the full contract amount. The judgment was reversed in part, and the trial court was directed to enter judgment requiring the contractor to refund its profit to the district. View "Davis v. Fresno Unified School Dist." on Justia Law

by
Two infrastructure companies formed a joint venture to bid on a Colorado highway express lane project, relying on engineering designs from a subsidiary of one partner. After winning the contract, the joint venture entered a subcontract with the engineering firm that incorporated many of their earlier terms but added a liability cap. During the project, disputes arose over the design work, resulting in multiple redesigns and delays. The engineering firm submitted change orders for additional work, but the joint venture either failed to process them according to contract procedures or “shelved” them as litigation began.The engineering firm sued the joint venture in the United States District Court for the District of Colorado, claiming breach of contract and unjust enrichment. The joint venture counterclaimed for breach of both the subcontract and the original teaming agreement, and later added a negligent misrepresentation claim. The district court dismissed the negligent misrepresentation counterclaim under the economic-loss rule and later granted summary judgment to the engineering firm on the teaming agreement counterclaim, holding that the subcontract superseded the earlier agreement and imposed a liability cap. The joint venture sought to add fraud counterclaims more than a year after the final pretrial order, but the district court denied this as untimely and prejudicial. The court also rejected the joint venture’s attempt to concede liability and assume the plaintiff’s role at trial, and denied its Rule 50 motions.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the district court’s rulings. The appellate court held that the district court did not err in denying the joint venture’s various motions, including its attempt to add new counterclaims, to instruct the jury on an implied duty of good faith and fair dealing, or to enter judgment against itself. The Tenth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment in favor of the engineering firm on all claims and counterclaims. View "AECOM Technical Services v. Flatiron | AECOM" on Justia Law

by
A national flooring retailer contracted with a Louisiana-based construction management company for the construction of a retail store in Metairie, Louisiana. The relationship soured after the retailer terminated the agreement, allegedly due to delays. Shortly after termination, the construction company disputed that it had breached the contract and demanded payment for work performed. The retailer did not respond to the payment demand.The construction company filed suit in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana under the Louisiana Private Works Act, seeking recovery for the work performed. The retailer moved to compel arbitration based on the agreement’s dispute resolution provision and also sought to transfer the case. The district court granted the transfer to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana and denied the motion to compel arbitration without prejudice. When the motion to compel arbitration was renewed in the new court, the district court denied it again, concluding the retailer had not followed the prerequisite steps outlined in the contract’s dispute resolution process.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit conducted de novo review. The appellate court determined that the arbitration clause in the contract, which gave the retailer sole discretion to elect arbitration, was a contract of adhesion under Louisiana law. Applying state contract principles and relevant Louisiana Supreme Court precedent, the court found that the lack of mutuality and the imbalance in bargaining power rendered the clause unenforceable. The court held that the arbitration provision was adhesionary and thus invalid, and affirmed the district court’s denial of the motion to compel arbitration. View "MAPP v. Floor and Decor" on Justia Law

by
A homeowner hired a general contractor to perform a remodeling project, which included electrical work provided by a subcontractor. During construction, a fire occurred at the home, allegedly due to improper electrical work by both the general contractor and the subcontractor. The homeowner’s insurer paid for the fire damage and, acting as subrogee, brought a negligence and breach of contract action against both contractors. After the fire, the homeowner discontinued the services of both contractors and later hired a new general contractor to complete the project.The Minnesota District Court granted summary judgment in favor of the contractors, dismissing the insurer’s claims as time-barred under the two-year statute of limitations for defective construction claims involving improvements to real property, as set out in Minn. Stat. § 541.051, subd. 1. The district court found that the statute of limitations began to run when the homeowner terminated the contract with the original general contractor, concluding that the action was not timely filed.On appeal, the Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed the district court's decision. The appellate court interpreted the statute to mean that the statute of limitations does not begin until the entire construction project is terminated, substantially completed, or abandoned, not merely upon termination of the contract with the general contractor.The Supreme Court of Minnesota reviewed the case to resolve the statutory interpretation issue. The court held that, for purposes of the statute of limitations under Minn. Stat. § 541.051, subd. 1, the termination of the contract with the general contractor constitutes “termination … of the construction or the improvement to real property.” As a result, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and reinstated the district court’s dismissal of the insurer’s claims as time-barred. View "American Family Insurance Company vs. NB Electric, Inc." on Justia Law

by
The case concerns a dispute arising from an oral agreement between a homeowner and a contractor regarding the construction of a wheelchair ramp and a covered addition at the homeowner’s residence. The parties did not sign a written contract or agree to a specific price, instead communicating the project’s scope via text messages. The homeowner paid the contractor $73,000, including $30,000 for siding, but the project was plagued by construction delays, quality concerns, and code violations. Work ceased before completion, and the contractor did not deliver or install the siding. The homeowner and his wife continued living in the property, though it did not receive a final certificate of compliance.The homeowner sued in the District Court of Sweetwater County, asserting claims including breach of contract, negligence, and breach of warranty. During discovery, the homeowner failed to provide a specific calculation of damages, only indicating he would supplement disclosures later. Before trial, the contractor moved to exclude any evidence of damages not previously disclosed. The district court partially granted this motion, limiting the homeowner’s evidence to what had been disclosed. At a bench trial, the homeowner did not call his retained expert and offered only the total amount paid as the measure of damages. The district court concluded the oral contract was unenforceable due to indefinite terms and found insufficient evidence to support a damages award.On appeal, the Supreme Court of Wyoming affirmed the district court’s rulings. The Supreme Court held that, because the homeowner failed to make an offer of proof regarding excluded damages evidence, there was no basis to review the trial court’s exclusionary ruling. The court further held that the district court’s finding—that the homeowner did not prove damages by a preponderance of the evidence—was not clearly erroneous. As the damages element was not satisfied, the Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal of the claims. View "Lacher v. Case" on Justia Law

by
The case concerns a dispute between a homeowner and the builder of his residence. The homeowner entered into a purchase agreement in 2014 for a newly constructed home, which included a one-year residential warranty. Shortly after moving in, he noticed significant cold drafts, frost buildup, and temperature differences in the northwest corner of the home. He raised these concerns with the builder and a local home builders association within the first year, and specifically requested an insulation check before the warranty expired. The builder coordinated multiple inspections and minor repairs with a subcontractor and later, after a period of inactivity, continued to address the issues through additional inspections and proposed repairs. Nevertheless, the homeowner did not commence legal action until July 2022, after an independent inspection revealed ongoing insulation defects.The District Court of Cass County, East Central Judicial District, dismissed the homeowner’s claims for breach of warranty, breach of contract, and negligence on summary judgment. The court found the claims were time-barred under North Dakota’s six-year statute of limitations, ruling that the homeowner was on inquiry notice of potential claims as early as December 28, 2015, when he specifically identified insulation concerns. The court also rejected arguments that the builder had waived or forfeited the statute of limitations defense due to litigation conduct, or that equitable estoppel should apply based on ongoing repair efforts.The Supreme Court of North Dakota affirmed the district court’s decision. It held that the homeowner was on inquiry notice of his claims by December 28, 2015, making his 2022 action untimely under N.D.C.C. § 28-01-16(1). The Court further held that the builder neither waived nor forfeited its limitations defense, that ongoing repair and settlement discussions did not equitably estop the builder from asserting the defense, and that no duty-to-disclose exception applied. The summary judgment dismissal was affirmed. View "Hanson v. Dabbert Custom Homes" on Justia Law

by
Black & Veatch Construction, Inc. contracted The Boldt Company as a subcontractor for the assembly of a windfarm in Illinois. The project quickly encountered delays due to late delivery of turbine parts, unsuitable site conditions, and issues with equipment, for which Boldt provided several written notices to Black & Veatch. Despite these notices, Black & Veatch issued multiple default warnings and ultimately terminated Boldt for cause, taking over the remaining work. Boldt sued, claiming wrongful termination and seeking payment for completed work, while Black & Veatch counterclaimed that Boldt breached by failing to perform on time.The United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois granted summary judgment in favor of Black & Veatch, ruling that Boldt defaulted by failing to perform on schedule and that Black & Veatch properly terminated the subcontract. At trial, the jury was tasked only with determining damages and awarded Black & Veatch nominal damages of $1. Both parties filed post-trial motions, which the district court denied.Upon appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed the jury’s nominal damages verdict, finding no reversible error in the district court’s evidentiary rulings or jury instructions. The appellate court also affirmed the district court’s grant of summary judgment as to Boldt’s claims for payment for completed work and for Black & Veatch’s alleged failure to provide adequate construction works. However, the Seventh Circuit reversed the grant of summary judgment on the wrongful termination claim, finding the subcontract ambiguous about whether Boldt was responsible for delays absent specific notice and that material factual disputes remained. The case was remanded for further proceedings on the wrongful termination claim. View "Boldt Company v Black & Veatch Construction, Inc." on Justia Law